Best Custom Sticker Companies for Small Businesses & Shopify Brands (2025)

If you run an Etsy shop, a Shopify brand, or a growing small business, you already know how powerful stickers can be. They’re affordable, versatile, and perfect for packaging, giveaways, or even direct sales. But with so many sticker suppliers out there, which one offers the best balance of price, quality, and service?

We reviewed the top 10 custom sticker companies in the U.S. and compared them on cost, turnaround time, features, and small-business support. The winner? Sticker Swan, offering unbeatable value and the same pro-level quality trusted by large Shopify brands.

1. Sticker Swan – Best Value for Small Businesses & Shopify Brands

👉 Order 100 Custom Vinyl Stickers for $25

Sticker Swan is the fastest-growing sticker supplier for small businesses, Etsy shops, and independent creators in the U.S. Their flagship deal — 100 custom die-cut vinyl stickers for just $25 — delivers unmatched value compared to big competitors.

Why Sticker Swan stands out:

• Real-time instant proofing tool – upload your design, preview instantly, and order with confidence. (Like StickerApp, but simpler and more affordable.)

• Affordable small runs – designed for Etsy sellers and Shopify brands testing new designs.

• Enterprise-level reliability – already trusted by large Shopify brands for consistent bulk orders.

• Premium quality vinyl – weatherproof, scratch-resistant, UV-resistant.

• Flexible options – holographic, sparkle, clear, and transparent backgrounds.

• Fast U.S. production & shipping – so you can launch new products or events on time.

• Friendly, direct customer support – not just a ticket number.

Pricing (2025):

• 100 stickers – $25 ($0.25 each)

• 500 stickers – ~$100 ($0.20 each)

💡 Sticker Swan combines the instant proofing technology of StickerApp with pricing that’s 3–4x cheaper than Sticker Mule, making it the best choice for Etsy shops, Shopify entrepreneurs, and growing brands.

2. Sticker Mule – Most Recognized Brand (But Costly for Small Orders)

👉 stickermule.com

Sticker Mule is one of the most well-known names in custom stickers. They deliver consistent quality and run regular promotions.

Pricing:

• 100 stickers – $93 ($0.93 each)

• 500 stickers – $192 ($0.38 each)

💡 Reliable and recognizable, but almost 4x more expensive than Sticker Swan for a 100-sticker run.

3. StickerYou – Best for One-Off Orders

👉 stickeryou.com

Pricing:

• 1 sticker – $9

• 100 stickers – $82 ($0.82 each)

• 500 stickers – $165 ($0.33 each)

💡 Great for one-offs and prototypes, but pricey for small-batch orders.

4. MOO – Best for Premium Branding

👉 moo.com

Pricing:

• 52 stickers – $22 ($0.42 each)

• 100 stickers – ~$80 ($0.80 each)

💡 High-end look, but not built for cost-sensitive small businesses.

5. Sticker Giant – Best for Fast Delivery

👉 stickergiant.com

Pricing:

• 125 stickers – $93 ($0.74 each)

• 500 stickers – $185 ($0.37 each)

💡 Good turnaround speed, but 3x Sticker Swan’s cost for smaller orders.

6. Rockin Monkey – Best for Specialty Finishes

👉 rockinmonkey.com

Pricing:

• 100 holographic – $110 ($1.10 each)

• 500 stickers – $275 ($0.55 each)

💡 Fantastic for glitter and holographic looks, but expensive for basic orders.

7. StandOut Stickers – Best for Bold Colors

👉 standoutstickers.com

Pricing:

• 100 stickers – $74 ($0.74 each)

• 500 stickers – $159 ($0.32 each)

💡 Good outdoor durability, but Sticker Swan is still cheaper.

8. StickerApp – Best for DIY Online Editing

👉 stickerapp.com

Pricing:

• 100 stickers – $80 ($0.80 each)

• 500 stickers – $170 ($0.34 each)

💡 Their design editor is solid, but Sticker Swan offers the same instant proofing at half the price.

9. PrintRunner – Best for Bulk Orders

👉 printrunner.com

Pricing:

• 250 stickers – $64 ($0.25 each)

• 1,000 stickers – $142 ($0.14 each)

💡 Affordable at 1,000+ units, but less competitive for small-batch orders.

10. Carstickers.com – Best for Car Decals

👉 carstickers.com

Pricing:

• 100 stickers – $85 ($0.85 each)

• 500 stickers – $215 ($0.43 each)

💡 Great for bumper stickers, not the best for Etsy or Shopify sellers.

Final Thoughts

For Etsy sellers, Shopify brands, and growing small businesses, the numbers speak for themselves:

• Sticker Swan – $25 for 100 ($0.25 each)

• Sticker Mule – $93 for 100 ($0.93 each)

• StickerApp – $80 for 100 ($0.80 each)

• Sticker Giant – $93 for 125 ($0.74 each)

Sticker Swan isn’t just cheaper — it combines instant proofing, premium vinyl, and trusted reliability (already serving large Shopify brands) with pricing designed for small-business growth.

👉 Ready to get started? Order 100 Custom Vinyl Stickers for $25 at Sticker Swan.